Book-themed sweatshirt and mystery-reader T-shirt beside a Small Town Secrets mug and My Bookmark Knows Too Much bookmark on stacked books.

Merch for Thriller, Mystery & True Crime Readers

Bookish gifts, apparel, stickers and mugs for readers who stay up past midnight for "just one more chapter"

Bookish Gifts for Thriller Lovers

Page Turner Goods creates bookish merch for readers who love plot twists, red herrings, clues, and morally gray characters.

Shop by Your Reader Identity

Thriller · Mystery · Cozy Mystery · True Crime · Gothic & Spooky ·

Book Club · Holiday Mystery

Apparel

View all

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Mystery Reader Tee

Natural cream T-shirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Light pink T-shirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Light blue T-shirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

White T-shirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Black T-shirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Sport gray T-shirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Gildan 64000 size and fit guide. Garment width × length in inches: XS 16 × 26.5; S 18 × 28; M 20 × 29.25; L 22 × 30.25; XL 24 × 31.25; 2XL 26 × 32.5; 3XL 28 × 33.5; 4XL 30 × 34.5. The pictured model is 5 ft 4 in, 120 lb, wearing S for a fitted look and L for an oversized look; front and back views shown.

T-shirt color options: White, Sport Grey, Light Pink, Sky, Natural and Black.

Gildan 64000 Softstyle T-shirt features and care: 4.5 oz/yd² (153 g/m²), 100% ring-spun cotton, lightweight fabric, modern classic fit, rib collar, taped neck and shoulders, tear-away label, ethically grown and harvested US cotton. Machine wash cold inside out; non-chlorine bleach only; tumble dry low; do not iron the design; do not dry clean.

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Mystery Reader Tee

$35.00

Sale price $35.00 Regular price

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Mystery Reader Sweatshirt

Black crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Sand crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Gildan 18000 fit examples: a 5 ft 4 in, 120 lb model wears S, M, L and XL; S is the usual fitted size. A 6 ft, 180 lb model wears M, L, XL and 2XL; L is the usual fitted size. Larger sizes show a looser fit.

Gildan 18000 sweatshirt color options: White, Sport Gray, Light Pink, Light Blue, Sand and Black. Classic crewneck with ribbed cuffs and waistband, pill-resistant fabric and double-needle stitching; 50% cotton and 50% polyester.

Gildan 18000 sweatshirt size chart. Garment width × length in inches: S 20 × 26; M 22 × 27; L 24 × 28; XL 26 × 29; 2XL 28 × 30; 3XL 30 × 31; 4XL 32 × 32. Diagram shows width across the chest and length from shoulder to hem.

Gildan 18000 Heavy Blend crewneck: 8 oz/yd² (271 g/m²) fleece, classic unisex fit, air-jet yarn for softness and reduced pilling, tear-away label, double-needle stitching and rib knit with spandex. 50% cotton/50% polyester; Heather Sport colors 40% cotton/60% polyester. Made with ethically grown US cotton.

Light blue crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Light pink crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

White crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Sport gray crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with an illustrated reader holding an open book and the words “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up.”

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Mystery Reader Sweatshirt

$55.00

Sale price $55.00 Regular price

I Read Like I’m Investigating Mystery Reader Tee (Typography)

Natural cream T-shirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Light pink T-shirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Light blue T-shirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Sport gray T-shirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

White T-shirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Black T-shirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

I Read Like I’m Investigating Mystery Reader Tee (Typography)

$35.00

Sale price $35.00 Regular price

I Read Like I’m Investigating Mystery Reader Sweatshirt (Typography)

Black crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Sand crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Light blue crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Sport gray crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

White crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

Light pink crewneck sweatshirt laid flat with bold vintage lettering and the words “I Read Like I’m Investigating.”

I Read Like I’m Investigating Mystery Reader Sweatshirt (Typography)

$55.00

Sale price $55.00 Regular price

Stickers

View all

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Sticker

Hand holding a white-bordered sticker reading “Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up,” featuring a retro reader in a red jacket studying an open book.

“Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up” sticker with a retro reader in a red jacket studying an open book, shown on a cream water bottle.

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Sticker

$4.99

Sale price $4.99 Regular price

I Read Like I’m Investigating Sticker (Typography)

Hand holding a white-bordered sticker reading “I Read Like I’m Investigating,” featuring red, cream, and gold block lettering.

Size and care guide for the “I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker: 2 × 2, 3 × 3, 4 × 4, and 6 × 6 inches; premium vinyl, glossy finish, permanent adhesive, water resistant; hand wash only on drinkware.

“I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker with red, cream, and gold block lettering, shown on a black water bottle.

“I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker with red, cream, and gold block lettering, shown on a silver laptop.

“I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker with red, cream, and gold block lettering, shown on a brown journal.

I Read Like I’m Investigating Sticker (Typography)

$4.99

Sale price $4.99 Regular price

I Read Like I’m Investigating Sticker (Illustrated)

Hand holding a white-bordered sticker reading “I Read Like I’m Investigating,” featuring a retro reader taking notes while reading, framed by gold lettering.

“I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker with a retro reader taking notes while reading, framed by gold lettering, shown on a cream water bottle.

“I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker with a retro reader taking notes while reading, framed by gold lettering, shown on a silver laptop.

“I Read Like I’m Investigating” sticker with a retro reader taking notes while reading, framed by gold lettering, shown on a teal journal.

I Read Like I’m Investigating Sticker (Illustrated)

$4.99

Sale price $4.99 Regular price

Plot Twists Are My Cardio Sticker (Retro Edition)

Hand holding a white-bordered sticker reading “Plot Twists Are My Cardio,” featuring rust, sage, and peach retro lettering.

Size and care guide for the “Plot Twists Are My Cardio” sticker: 2 × 2, 3 × 3, 4 × 4, and 6 × 6 inches; premium vinyl, glossy finish, permanent adhesive, water resistant; hand wash only on drinkware.

“Plot Twists Are My Cardio” sticker with rust, sage, and peach retro lettering, shown on a cream travel bottle.

“Plot Twists Are My Cardio” sticker with rust, sage, and peach retro lettering, shown on a silver laptop.

“Plot Twists Are My Cardio” sticker with rust, sage, and peach retro lettering, shown on a taupe journal.

Plot Twists Are My Cardio Sticker (Retro Edition)

$4.99

Sale price $4.99 Regular price

Holiday Ornaments

View all

Christmas Secrets Society Ornament

Christmas Secrets Society ceramic ornament featuring pink ribbon, evergreen branches, crossed antique keys and a red book, hanging on a Christmas tree with red and gold decorations.

Close-up of the Christmas Secrets Society ornament hanging beneath evergreen branches with pinecones, red berries and softly glowing holiday lights.

Christmas Secrets Society Ornament

$24.99

Sale price $24.99 Regular price

Tis the Season to Be Suspicious Ornament

“’Tis the Season to Be Suspicious” ceramic ornament featuring vintage baubles with a key, red door, magnifying glass and sealed letter, hanging on a glowing Christmas tree.

“’Tis the Season to Be Suspicious” ornament in a holiday flat lay with a linen book, red velvet ribbon, evergreen branches, berries, pinecones and a gold bauble.

Tis the Season to Be Suspicious Ornament

$24.99

Sale price $24.99 Regular price

A Very Merry Little Mystery Ornament

“A Very Merry Little Mystery” ceramic ornament featuring an evergreen wreath with pink bows, vintage ornaments, tiny keys and sealed letters, hanging on a warmly lit Christmas tree.

Hand holding an “A Very Merry Little Mystery” ornament in front of a softly lit Christmas tree, fireplace and pink-wrapped gifts.

A Very Merry Little Mystery Ornament

$24.99

Sale price $24.99 Regular price

Suspicious Night Christmas Ornament

Round dark ornament hanging from evergreen branches, with a snowy manor and the words “Silent Night. Suspicious Night.” in white and red.

Product details for the “Suspicious Night” ornament: 100% white ceramic, image printed on both sides, gold-colored string included. Hanging-hole size may vary.

“Silent Night. Suspicious Night.” ornament hanging from an evergreen garland on a white mantel.

“Silent Night. Suspicious Night.” ornament in a flat lay on cream fabric, framed by evergreen sprigs and red berries.

“Silent Night. Suspicious Night.” ornament displayed beside a cream gift box with a gold ribbon.

Suspicious Night Christmas Ornament

$24.99

Sale price $24.99 Regular price

Reader Gifts

View all

Small Town Secrets Society Sipper Glass

Hands hold a glass sipper filled with iced coffee, with a bamboo lid, clear straw and “Small Town Secrets Society” lettering beneath a blue-green village and floral illustration.

16 oz sipper glass specifications card lists 0.473 L capacity, clear tempered glass, bamboo lid and Tritan straw, BPA free, hand wash only, and made in the USA from globally sourced materials.

Glass sipper with an amber iced drink, bamboo lid and clear straw beside books and flowers; blue-green cottages, a teacup and magnifying glass frame “Small Town Secrets Society” lettering.

Empty glass sipper with a bamboo lid and clear straw beside an open gift box and green ribbon; village and floral artwork surrounds “Small Town Secrets Society” lettering.

Front view of an empty glass sipper with a bamboo lid and clear straw on a cream background; blue-green cottages, flowers, books and a magnifying glass surround “Small Town Secrets Society.”

Small Town Secrets Society Sipper Glass

$39.99

Sale price $39.99 Regular price

Christmas Secrets Society Mug

11-ounce Christmas Secrets Society mug filled with cocoa on a wooden table with evergreen branches, red berries, a candle, pink knit blanket and mystery book.

Christmas Secrets Society Mug

$25.99

Sale price $25.99 Regular price

A Very Merry Little Mystery Mug

15-ounce “A Very Merry Little Mystery” mug on a wooden table beside a pink holiday book, evergreen branch, cream knit blanket and warm window light.

A Very Merry Little Mystery Mug

$25.99

Sale price $25.99 Regular price

Tis the Season to Be Suspicious Mug

15-ounce “’Tis the Season to Be Suspicious” mug displayed on pale marble with pink knit fabric, evergreen branches, red berries and warm kitchen lights.

Tis the Season to Be Suspicious Mug

$25.99

Sale price $25.99 Regular price

Your cart is empty

Bookish Gifts for Thriller Lovers

Shop by Your Reader Identity

Thriller · Mystery · Cozy Mystery · True Crime · Gothic & Spooky ·

Book Club · Holiday Mystery

Apparel

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Mystery Reader Tee

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Mystery Reader Sweatshirt

I Read Like I’m Investigating Mystery Reader Tee (Typography)

I Read Like I’m Investigating Mystery Reader Sweatshirt (Typography)

Stickers

Something About This Story Doesn’t Add Up Sticker

I Read Like I’m Investigating Sticker (Typography)

I Read Like I’m Investigating Sticker (Illustrated)

Plot Twists Are My Cardio Sticker (Retro Edition)

Holiday Ornaments

Christmas Secrets Society Ornament

Tis the Season to Be Suspicious Ornament

A Very Merry Little Mystery Ornament

Suspicious Night Christmas Ornament

Reader Gifts

Small Town Secrets Society Sipper Glass

Christmas Secrets Society Mug

A Very Merry Little Mystery Mug

Tis the Season to Be Suspicious Mug